How to Grade Retro Game Condition Like a Pro

Consistent Grading = Customer Trust

Customers return to stores they trust. Consistent, honest grading builds that trust and reduces returns.

Grading Cartridge-Based Games

Label Condition

• Check for tears, fading, sticker residue, and marker writing
• Sun-faded labels drop condition by at least one grade

Cart Shell

• Look for cracks, discoloration, and missing screws
• Check pin connector for corrosion or bent pins

Functionality

• Always test before grading
• Check save batteries on games that use them (SNES RPGs, Game Boy titles)

Grading Disc-Based Games

Disc Surface

• Hold at an angle under light to check for scratches
• Deep scratches that catch a fingernail will likely affect playability
• Resurfacing can improve condition but should be disclosed

Case and Manual

• Check for cracks in jewel cases or DVD cases
• Manual condition matters — water damage and missing pages reduce value

Photography Tips

Take clear, well-lit photos of:

1. Front label/cover
2. Back of cart/disc
3. Any damage or notable wear
4. Box and manual (if included)

Good photos speed up AI grading and give customers confidence in your listings.